Re: Spaceship One - a partial sucess.

From: Bruce Hoult (bruce_at_hoult.org)
Date: 09/30/04


Date: Thu, 30 Sep 2004 21:17:22 +1200

In article <u4K6d.65$2B6.54148@news.uswest.net>,
 "Christopher M. Jones" <marmiteNOTSPAM@dualboot.net> wrote:

> > And always will, with that design. Once it gets out of the atmosphere
> > it simply doesn't have enough authority on the attitide control jets to
> > compensate for the variations in thrust vector you're always going to
> > get from a rocket with solid fuel.
> >
> > The higher a flight is aiming for, the worse the problem will be.
>
> This is bunk. The problem on the first flight was straight
> up Pilot Induced Oscillation. The cause for the second
> problem is unknown but considering it was a roll problem
> it's very, very unlikely to be due to thrust variations
> (which would induce pitch or yaw variations).

Then you didn't watch the June flight very carefully.

There was a roll each way just after engine ignition. This is
presumably what you are talking about.

But then there was another uncommanded roll in the last seconds before
engine cutout, much as with this flight, but less.

-- Bruce



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Spaceship One - a partial sucess.
    ... >> it simply doesn't have enough authority on the attitide control jets to ... >> compensate for the variations in thrust vector you're always going to ... pure roll excursion. ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • Re: Spaceship One - a partial sucess.
    ... >> compensate for the variations in thrust vector you're always going to ... >> The higher a flight is aiming for, the worse the problem will be. ... might not win the X Prize, but if it does so despite its qualifying ... especially if better craft lost because they preferred to ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • Re: Broad 93 mph
    ... unconvinced that variation of pace ... outside these other variations is important. ... flight. ... So sometimes you would see six balls all different; ...
    (uk.sport.cricket)
  • Re: Spaceship One - a partial sucess.
    ... > compensate for the variations in thrust vector you're always going to ... The problem on the first flight was straight ... up Pilot Induced Oscillation. ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • Re: Testing number due theory
    ... Let us look at the 19th roll. ... in 1828 rolls you would have saved money because you felt the 7 was ... but I suspect than none of the variations you see ... from the expected 16.67% are more than random noise. ...
    (rec.gambling.craps)