Re: Planet Definition revised

steve wrote:
See:-

http://www.space.com/scienceastronomy/060819_new_proposal.html


It is proposed that part of the planet definition should be a
requirement that :-

(a) is by far the largest object in its local population[1],
[1] The local population is the collection of objects that cross or
close approach the orbit of the body in consideration.


I can see that Pluto would by this lose its right to being a planet due

to Neptune.


But what of two similar sized objects the size of Earth in the same
orbit, maybe even orbiting each other as a binary system (whilst still
orbiting their star). surely these deserve to be planets


I still think the previous rules about the position of the COG make
more sense, and making the cut off size some arbitary size big enough
to keep the proposed number of planets to a reasonable number is
sensible.


I would simply say make this size bigger (or equal) than Pluto if we
still want Pluto.
Or
Bigger than (or equal to ) Mercury .


The idea of using a size big enough to make sphere by gravitational
forces might be elegant but is rather small , resulting in many more
planets than we can sensibly handle.

Pluto should not be a planet. It's a kiper belt asteroid.

--
Linux is just a fancy name for Windows blocker.

Claude Hopper
.

Relevant Pages

  • 10th Planet "Discovered"
    ... Object Bigger than Pluto Discovered, Called 10th Planet ... The announcement, made today by Mike Brown of Caltech, came just hours ... eluded discovery: nobody was looking there until now, ...
    (sci.space.shuttle)
  • 10th Planet "Discovered"
    ... Object Bigger than Pluto Discovered, Called 10th Planet ... The announcement, made today by Mike Brown of Caltech, came just hours ... eluded discovery: nobody was looking there until now, ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • A whole new world?
    ... A recently discovered "planet" beyond the orbit of Pluto has been discovered... ... This new object is even bigger then Pluto... ... 2003 UB313's discovery with colleagues last July, ...
    (soc.culture.irish)
  • Re: Sanity returns to astronomy
    ... Pluto no longer a planet, ... Czech Republic -- Leading astronomers declared Thursday ... "a celestial body that is in orbit around the sun, ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: "Pluto Now Called a Plutoid"
    ... Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, Pluto, and Eris. ... So clearly these are not what the IAU had in mind. ... planet, for those who've tried to come up with generalizations to, say, ... The IAU has a number of catalogues; the footnote lists the ...
    (rec.arts.sf.science)