Re: Back to the moon? When?



Ian Parker wrote:
Is there any point in manned spaceflight at all? Logically no.
Everything can be done by robots at a far lower cost. The only point
in manned spaceflight is if colonization is on the table. Personally I
feel this to be a pipedream as far as the foreseeable future is
concerned.

The Apollo missions actually proved why everything can't be done by
robots. The astronauts were able to pick and choose which lunar
samples to send back, and so much more was learned from their samples
than those sent back by the Lunokhod missions.

But what robots _can_ do, indeed, they do accomplish at much lower
cost. And given the great advances in computers since the 1960s, I
suppose that a Mars sample return mission could return samples picked
up by a Mars rover in response to instructions from Earth.

But those Mars samples really ought to be studied in a lab on the Moon
or in orbit, because there could be life on Mars.

John Savard

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Why manned exploration of space?
    ... things in a few days that robots can *never* do, ... That robots are sent off on space exploration missions totally ... to specifically designing robotic missions to do the job. ... If you're calling changing out physical hardware "reprogramming," ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Re: Why manned exploration of space?
    ... The abilities of humans still vastly outstrip those of ... things in a few days that robots can *never* do, ... The success rate for Mars missions is a tad under 50%, ... course - could have been fixed by a robotic mission. ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Re: Why manned exploration of space?
    ... things that humans can't in a few days. ... things in a few days that robots can *never* do, ... the line can REPROGRAM the robots to deal with it, ... The success rate for Mars missions is a tad under 50%, ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Re: Robots - our helpers in space
    ... > funding that they believe would otherwise be spent on unmanned exploration. ... I am all for manned exploration. ... sucking up money that could've been spent on discovery missions to the ... teleoperated robots would be very valuable tools. ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • Re: We, first loosers for 100 years.
    ... missions, ... Don't forget that a lot of the engineers who worked on Apollo came from ... What the Chinese sell is cheap labour. ... Not 9 to 5 robots and certainly not bonus-focused board members. ...
    (sci.space.moderated)