Two peoples having February Matching birth and Bob´s stubbornness



Is rarer than to all the other months of the year (under the condition of uniformity)of course.

When Bob says that (quoting):

*** ...he said my approximate formula [dividing the year in 12 months each with 30 days] was wrong because I didn´t count the number of days of each month.***

Now I call the attention of the Readers by he Bob´s follow-up:

***...The 1/12 approximation of the 2nd person born on the same MONTH as the randomly chosen 1st is no different from 1/365 used as the aprox. probability of the same person on the same day ***

This is NECESSARY and SUFFICIENT to the Readers decide who is RIGHT
The length of time DAY is the same all over the year, the MONTHS (because have number of days) have different lengths.
I scarcely understand how Bob can assume that
___to find at least two persons born on FEBRUARY has the same probability than to find at least two persons born on (say) December.

_______licas (Luis A. Afonso)
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: The ASC Troll Experiment.
    ... Since attention is what he wants, ... Bob Borgeson ... Frank Seltzer ... YOU GOT TO BE A FUCKIN IDIOT, HOW LONG HAVE BEEN POSTING HERE. ...
    (alt.smokers.cigars)
  • Re: The ASC Troll Experiment.
    ... Since attention is what he wants, ... Tim Powell ... Tom Scheeler ... Bob Austin ...
    (alt.smokers.cigars)
  • Re: ATWT Will Jack Finally Ditch Carly? SPOILER
    ... I don't remember if Bob is the youngest, ... > 21 years old when he was born. ... Tom is Nancy's grandson. ... Casey is Nancy's great-grandson. ...
    (rec.arts.tv.soaps.cbs)
  • Re: birthdays at the same month as a function of N of members
    ... All the Readers agree, I think, that this e-mail shows once more, two main things: Bob is seriously ill, in my opinion. ... DISLEXY and HISTERY. ... He did not read what Chapkovski asked: and I had the opportunity to stress: not pbut just the inverse n. ...
    (sci.stat.math)
  • Re: OT: Left wing Jew haters, heres your chance!
    ... It's so good of you, VV, to promote peace and harmony here on Earth by ... You'll never catch the Bob T's ... taught from the day you were born that jews are less than human, ...
    (rec.gambling.poker)