Re: Small Markov models problem



Ross Clement (Email address invalid - do not use) wrote:
Now, my real problem is this: My actual models are two extremes. One
is calculated with an independence assumption between two variables
in
underlying details which I haven't explained. The second is
calculated
with an assumption that these same two variables are equivalent. I
would like to claim that the "intermediate" models show varying
degrees of dependence between the two variables, from 0 (full
independence) to
1.0 (full dependence/equivalence).


I think that most modellers would want to work with the conditional
probabilities and to use these to judge whether a model showed more or
less dependence than another. However, working with conditional
probabilities leaves the extra step of having to fix-up the marginal
distibutions to remain the same. For your model (treating the 0.3, 0.7
weights a derived from a parameter), can you derive the conditional
probabilities and show that that the parameter has the effect of
indicating more or less dependence in terms of the conditional
probabilities?

David Jones


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Multiple comparison correction using p values alone
    ... Of course Jerry is referring to problems with independence when he ... asserts Pis not P*P, ... probabilities, not p values, there would be less kerfuffle. ... posterior probabilities of 0.95 for each of two lineages of the split, ...
    (sci.stat.consult)
  • Re: Small Markov models problem
    ... probabilities leaves the extra step of having to fix-up the marginal ... indicating more or less dependence in terms of the conditional ... I think that I converted the representation of the Markov model to the ... state probabilities pand premained the same, ...
    (sci.stat.math)
  • Dependence in PI is More Optimal Than Independence and Applications to Brownian Motion and Poisson P
    ... Copyright by Owner Osher Doctorow Ph.D. ... Dependence in PI is More Optimal Than Independence and Applications ... the optimality extends "across the board". ...
    (sci.stat.math)
  • Re: FFT test with few kbits
    ... >> Italian mathematician to hear his thought. ... (The standard english mathematical term is "necessary" condition) ... > in other word, increasing n, the independence is stronger. ... dependence between two Fourier components becomes ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Re: Independence Further Examined in PI
    ... especially the case for "independence" in statistics, ... "dependence" appears with qualifiers in statistics are almost ... negative quadrant dependence is also of considerable interest. ...
    (sci.stat.math)