Re: Multinomial approximation to Poisson ??


Nag wrote:
Reef fish: You seem to love the sound of your own words.

Only to debunk false accusations.


As you said, the other reader pointed out some issues related to
convergence of Binomial to Poisson. Those are standard and well-known
and anyone who can solve my problem will be aware of them.

But obviously not well-known to YOU, as you had also made an
error in your statement of the Binomial which the other poster exposed.


An expert is someone who can help with formulating a problem. If my
problem is not well-defined, as you seem so fond of saying, an expert
will point out where it needs to be changed.

That's what EVERYONE in the thread said of your description of your
problem. It was ill-defined and ill-described.

se16@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx had already pointed out your errors and
gave you hints about your multinomial, which you seemed to have
completely overlooked.


Obviously you are not one. Do me a favor and stop hijacking this
thread. Of course I will not be responding to your comments.

Best
Nag

No body is hijacking this or any other thread. The only thing worse
than someone who doesn't even know enough to ask a question is
one who is belligerent when others had already given him hints on
where he went wrong and one who insisted on his (3)

Nag> 3. I have no interest in looking at other other ways of solving
Nag> the problem.

when Nag didn't even know which way to look in the first place, but
smart-donkey enough to insist of looking no other ways.

As I had said, "Good luck, you're on your own".

-- Reef Fish Bob.

.